Trainio

Hold your ground on an unproven treatment request

A member who heard about a trendy protocol on a podcast and wants it added to his plan now. Learner must hold the clinical line without condescending, explain the reasoning, and keep the relationship — and the plan — intact.

  • Holding clinical boundaries
  • Explaining without condescending
  • Preserving the relationship

One of 35 boundaries & professionalism scenarios in the library.

Brett Kaufman, AI avatarAI avatar · Wellness

Brett Kaufman

Member requesting a treatment

“I want to talk about adding that protocol I mentioned. I don't get why we're not trying it.”

Hold your ground on an unproven treatment request

Your brief

Wellness & performanceAI avatar · ~5 minScored: Percentage

You are entering a conversation with Brett, a wellness member who wants a trendy protocol added to his plan after hearing about it on a podcast. He feels invested in the idea and may read a refusal as closed-mindedness or dismissal. Your goal is to hold the clinical boundary clearly, explain the reasoning in a respectful way, and keep Brett engaged with the plan and the relationship. Aim to leave the conversation with trust intact and a clear path forward.

Why it's hard

Brett isn’t really debating evidence; he’s testing whether you can hear him without treating him like someone who got fooled by a podcast. Say no too bluntly and he hears contempt, but if you soften the line just to keep him happy, you let outside hype start steering the plan.

  • A podcast shaped his expectation
  • He wants it added now
  • Refusal can sound dismissive
  • Trust rides on your tone

What to say when a member pushes for a trendy protocol

Acknowledge Brett's interest, explain clearly why you are not adding it now, then offer the next review step. What people get wrong is sounding dismissive or stopping at no. You need a plain reason tied to safety, evidence, or fit, and a clear next step so you keep trust.

I want to talk about adding that protocol I mentioned. I don't get why we're not trying it.

I hear why it caught your attention, Brett. I'm not adding it right now because we don't have enough evidence that it fits your plan safely.

So we're just ignoring new ideas because I heard it on a podcast?

No. I'm taking your question seriously. For now, we stay with your current plan, and I can bring this up through our clinical review process.

Why it worked: You stayed calm, respected Brett's interest, and gave a clear reason for the no. You also held the line and ended with a next step.

Avoid saying

“We don't do that here, so let's move on.”

It sounds dismissive and gives no reason, so Brett is more likely to feel brushed off.

What good looks like

  • Stay calm and professional from start to finish, even if Brett repeats the request or sounds irritated.
  • Acknowledge what appealed to him about the protocol and his frustration about hearing no; treat the podcast source respectfully.
  • Explain in plain language why you are not adding it right now, tying your answer to evidence, safety, fit with his plan, or what your program appropriately offers.
  • Hold the boundary when he pushes, and do not drift into a vague maybe or agree without a sound clinical reason.
  • End with a clear next step, like continuing the current plan, talking through an in-scope alternative, or outlining the proper review path to revisit the request.

Your score in this scenario comes from these behaviors. Practice until they're your default.

Frequently asked questions

What is unproven treatment request training?

Unproven treatment request training is practice for saying no to a trendy protocol while keeping the member's trust. A realistic AI avatar plays Brett Kaufman, who heard about it on a podcast and wants it added now. You get a percentage score and notes on how well you held the boundary and kept the relationship.

Can I practice with Brett before signing up?

You can practice with Brett before signing up, right here in your browser. A realistic AI avatar plays Brett Kaufman, and the preview runs up to five minutes. Enter your work email first to start. Your camera is never used. When it ends, you get a score and notes on what you said.

How do you say no to a trendy protocol without sounding closed-minded?

Start by naming what the member is reacting to: hope, curiosity, or frustration. Then give a plain-language reason for the decision and connect it to evidence, safety, fit, or program scope. The tone matters as much as the boundary; people hear disrespect fast when they feel attached to the idea.

What if the member keeps pushing after you’ve explained your reasoning?

Repeat the decision clearly without getting sharper each time. Briefly restate the reason, then move to what you can do next: continue the current plan, discuss an alternative that fits, or explain the proper clinical path for reconsideration. The goal is to avoid turning the exchange into an argument about who is right.

More boundaries & professionalism scenarios

See all →
Aisha Mensah

Aisha Mensah

Outpatient client

Boundaries & professionalismOngoingCoaching

Set limits on repeated crisis calls

A client repeatedly calls the program after hours for reassurance but is not describing an immediate emergency. The AI becomes hurt and angry when redirected, insisting that no one cares. Learner must validate distress, assess for urgent risk, reinforce appropriate contact boundaries, and connect the client to the agreed support plan.

Skills you'll train

  • Boundary setting
  • Brief risk screening
  • Supportive redirection
Darnell Bishop

Darnell Bishop

group therapy participant

Boundaries & professionalismOngoingCoaching

Redirect a client disrupting group therapy

During an outpatient skills group, Darnell repeatedly interrupts peers, challenges the facilitator, and starts pulling others into side arguments. He becomes louder when redirected, then softens if his concern is acknowledged without giving up the group structure. The learner must set a respectful limit, protect other members’ airtime, and offer an appropriate next step.

Skills you'll train

  • Limit-setting
  • Group facilitation
  • De-escalation
Owen Sethi

Owen Sethi

group therapy participant

Boundaries & professionalismComplianceCoaching

Repair a group confidentiality breach

After group, Owen tells the facilitator he recognized another member’s story online and has been discussing it with a mutual acquaintance. He insists it was public information and becomes defensive when told the impact on group safety. The learner must address the breach promptly, reinforce group confidentiality expectations, and determine what follow-up and escalation are needed without publicly shaming him.

Skills you'll train

  • Confidentiality boundaries
  • Restorative communication
  • Incident escalation

Roll it out to your whole team

Send this scenario to one role or one site. You set the pass mark and see who's ready before it's real.